What do you think of these shoes? (which one?)?

I like them both a lot. Get whichever one is cheaper. Some of the other answers told you to get pink shoes or coach shoes, something more 'girlie'. Personally, I think they look better in black than in pink or in some weird design. It's not emo or anything, I just think that black shoes are easier to match with different outfits... but get whatever color you like!